Archive for June, 2012

be productively stupid

Swiped from the incredibly smart Deborah Kwon:

Productive stupidity means being ignorant by choice. Focusing on important questions puts us in the awkward position of being ignorant. One of the beautiful things about science is that it allows us to bumble along, getting it wrong time after time, and feel perfectly fine as long as we learn something each time. No doubt, this can be difficult for students who are accustomed to getting the answers right. No doubt, reasonable levels of confidence and emotional resilience help, but I think scientific education might do more to ease what is a very big transition: from learning what other people once discovered to making your own discoveries. The more comfortable we become with being stupid, the deeper we will wade into the unknown and the more likely we are to make big discoveries.

to isaiah

Reading this was like being punched in the stomach (in the best possible way):

(Passed on from Eugene Kim, whose patients are lucky to have him)

hear hear

We Americans take these institutions for granted. We assume that private enterprise generates what is so casually called “innovation” all by itself. It does not. The Web browser you are using to read this essay was invented at the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign. The code that makes this page possible was invented at a publicly funded academic research center in Switzerland. That search engine you use many times a day, Google, was made possible by a grant from the National Science Foundation to support Stanford University. You didn’t get polio in your youth because of research done in the early 1950s at Case Western Reserve University. California wine is better because of the University of California at Davis. Hollywood movies are better because of UCLA. And your milk was not spoiled this morning because of work done at the University of Wisconsin at Madison.

These things did not just happen because someone saw a market opportunity and investors and inventors rushed off to meet it. That’s what happens in business-school textbooks. In the real world, we roll along, healthy and strong, in the richest nation in the world because some very wise people decided decades ago to invest in institutions that serve no obvious short-term purpose. The results of the work we do can take decades to matter—if at all. Most of what we do fails. Some succeeds. The system is terribly inefficient. And it’s supposed to be that way…

Instead of holding up their responsibility, states are divesting themselves of the commitment to help their young people achieve social mobility. States are rigging the system so that only the wealthy can compete for slots in the best universities. States shift the cost of higher education from taxpayers—all of whom benefit from living in a wiser, more creative society—to the students themselves. Yet students keep coming, desperate to enter the privileged classes, unable to imagine a different way through a cruel economy that has no use for the uneducated any more.

Universities are supposed to be special places where we let young people imagine a better world. They are supposed to be able to delay the pressures of the daily grind for a few years. They are supposed to be able to aspire to greatness and inspire each other. A tiny few will aspire to be poets. Many more will aspire to be engineers. Some will become both. Along the way they will bond with friends, meet lovers, experience hangovers, make mistakes, and read some mind-blowing books.

Does that sound wasteful? Does that sound inefficient? Nostalgic? Out-of-sync with the times? Damn right it does. But if we don’t want young people of all backgrounds to experiment with ideas and identities because it seems too expensive to support, we have to ask ourselves what sort of society we are trying to become.

Higher education is not one system. There are multiple layers and a wide variety of institutions. But they all have one thing in common: They have a mission to use knowledge to empower people to imagine a better life and transform society. If we like where we are, let’s just forget about it and roll back public support for higher education. But if we aspire to better things as a society, not just as individuals, then we should rediscover the vision of public higher education that inspired the University of Virginia in the first place.

[not to exalt unnecessary inefficiency, but sometimes it’s part of the process]


New data bank for anything related to Korean Americans:

In other news, just booked tickets to Houston for 2nd reunion of our race/religion seminar…looking forward to good times (in the air conditioning–Houston in August!) with this fantastic interdisciplinary family of scholars. Also you heard it here first–the caramelized peach salad at Adele’s is delicious.


…a new study to be released on Tuesday shows that immigrants played a role in more than three out of four patents at the nation’s top research universities. 

[lollipop that prevents tooth decay = brilliant]

karaoke and politics

For instance, Assemblyman Edward P. Ra, Republican of Long Island, became supportive of a measure to create a fund to help illegal immigrants pay for college after casual chats with Mr. Moya at karaoke. “It was just two friends discussing an issue and why it was important to him and his community,” Mr. Ra said. “It made it more personal.”

But karaoke is about the spectacle more than the sidebars.

A crowd favorite is a Senate staff member who covers Cee Lo Green’s “Forget You” (better than Cee Lo himself, some say) and does a split during his performance. Assemblyman Andrew P. Raia, another Long Island Republican, works the crowd as he sings, holding a cordless microphone and twisting through a dancing mob as he belts out “Sweet Caroline” and implores his fellow revelers to join in.

vincent chin, 30 years later